Episode 170: Paper Armor

Air Date: June 29, 2011

A person can increase his chances of surviving an underwater explosion by floating on his back at the surface.

confirmed

Adam and Jamie built a 15 ft (5 m) deep cylindrical tank, fitted it with pressure sensors at four depths, and filled it with water. Firing an underwater .357 Magnum revolver loaded with blanks to generate shock waves, they found that the sensor nearest the surface gave the lowest readings.

For full-scale tests, they used a mast fitted with sensors at depths of 0, 0.5, 2.5, 15, and 25 ft (0, 0.15, 0.76, 4.6, and 7.6 m). The first several depths were intended to represent the depth at which a swimmer’s torso would be submerged if he were floating or treading water. A 10 lb (5 kg) charge of TNT was set off at a depth of 15 ft (5 m) and at a certain horizontal distance from the sensors (30, 70, or 150 ft (9, 21, or 46 m)).

Using a pressure threshold of 87 psi (corresponding to a 50% mortality rate from the shock wave), Adam and Jamie found that a person 30 ft (9 m) from the explosion would survive if floating, but the pressures at greater depths were likely to cause death. At longer distances, readings at all depths fell below 87 psi. Based on the 30-foot results, they declared the myth confirmed. Jamie attributed these results to the fact that much of the energy from the underwater pressure wave dissipated into transverse waves when it reached the surface.

Ancient Chinese armies used armor made from paper that could give the same protection as steel armor.

plausible

Kari spoke with antique armor expert Greg Martin, who explained that paper armor was in use as early as 600 BC and was built up from layers that may have been impregnated with resin or shellac. The Build Team tested several formulations for penetration resistance and found that a thick layer of folded paper, with no resin, gave the best results.

Using an armor sample of either 1/2 in (13 mm) paper or 1/32 in (1 mm) steel placed over a block of clay, they tested resistance to blunt force, swords, and arrows. The paper did as well as steel in the sword and arrow tests, failing only the blunt-force test, so the team decided to build a full suit of paper armor to match against a period-accurate steel counterpart.

Each team member ran one of three timed courses in both armor types to evaluate speed, endurance, and agility; paper outperformed steel in all three. Finally, they attacked the suits with arrows, swords, and two different firearms—an 18th-century flintlock pistol and a 19th-century .45 revolver. Both armor types resisted every attack except the .45, leading the team to classify the myth as plausible. They pointed out, though, that the paper armor could quickly begin to disintegrate if it got wet or took repeated blows (both of which happened during the full-scale tests).

5 Comments

  1. Don says:

    Regarding the paper armor, I suppose the main disadvantage would be if they were hit by a flaming arrow or were around incendiaries!

  2. rdog says:

    The shield was made of paper that had resin added in it WHILE it was being made. And so a flaming arrow wouldn’t really affect it.

  3. xizor2000 says:

    Well, I wanted to point out that the actual paper armor is also lacquered. That means there is some water-proofing there. Otherwise it would be utterly disastrous when it rains! In fact, I suspect it might be the same lacquer the Chinese applied on their ships which they sent all the way to East Africa too.

    • James says:

      Paper armor applied lacguer. Is. Water proofing and
      Made the armor. Stronger and. The Chinese applied
      Lacguer. To all ther. Armor. The. Steel. Too so. Ther
      Applied lacguer. To the. Paper armor. Too

  4. William Zehnpfund says:

    In reference to episode 170 Chinese paper armor. I think you may have missed a stepnin your construction of the armor. The Chinese battelfield was a very colorful place, by adding color you could control your forces better. If you socked the rice paper in tinted shalac are varnish, then fold it to make the armor billets, not only would you add color, but you would harden the armor more and add water proffing.

Leave a Reply

(required)